Test Shows Pedestrian Systems Not as Effective as Claimed

Test Shows Pedestrian Systems Not as Effective as Claimed

The American Automobile Association (AAA) released the results of a study involving four popular cars equipped with pedestrian detection, and the numbers are dismal, to say the least.

The AAA-initiated research shows that automatic emergency braking (AEB) systems designed to detect pedestrians performed inconsistently, and were completely ineffective at night when they were needed most.

For the study, AAA tested four cars: a 2019 Chevrolet Malibu, 2019 Honda Accord, 2019 Toyota Camry, and 2019 Tesla Model 3. The first three cars are available locally.

AAA found that the respective pedestrian detection systems--Chevrolet's Front Pedestrian Braking, Honda's Honda Sensing, Toyota's Safety Sense, and Tesla's AEB--were 'significantly challenged' in the different test scenarios they were tested in using adult and child-sized dummy pedestrians.

"Pedestrian fatalities are on the rise, proving how important the safety impact of these systems could be when further developed," said Greg Brannon, AAA's director of Automotive Engineering and Industry Relations. "But, our research found that current systems are far from perfect and still require an engaged driver behind the wheel."

The inability of the four systems to detect pedestrians when the sun goes down proves to be the most controversial result of all, as nighttime is when most pedestrian fatalities occur, according to numerous studies.

Aside from time of day, AAA also cites vehicle speed as a major contributing factor to pedestrian fatalities.

"A pedestrian hit by a vehicle traveling at 20 mph (32 kph) has an 18 percent risk of severe injury or death," according to the AAA. "Increase that by just 10 mph to 30 mph (16 kph to 48 kph) and the risk more than doubles to 47 percent."

"AAA's latest study found that speed impacted system performance as well, with results varying between testing performed at 20 mph and 30 mph (32 kph and 48 kph)," AAA added.

AAA worries that the way carmakers advertise these features, drivers may be left with the impression that they are more effective than real-world testing shows.

"It's going to be a little while before the effectiveness of the system catches up with the marketing, unfortunately," said Brannon.

You may view the AAA study here.

Image by Masashi Wakui from Pixabay

Read All

Featured Articles

Recommended Articles For You

Read All

Car Articles From Zigwheels

  • News
  • Article Feature
  • Advisory Stories
  • Road Test
  • BAIC PH previews 5-car lineup prior to public launch
    BAIC PH previews 5-car lineup prior to public launch
    Ruben Manahan IV . Today
  • Bentley, PUBG Mobile team up to bring 'opulence to battleground'
    Bentley, PUBG Mobile team up to bring 'opulence to battleground'
    Ruben Manahan IV . Today
  • ‘Mixed’ pump price adjustments set for tomorrow
    ‘Mixed’ pump price adjustments set for tomorrow
    Ruben Manahan IV . Mar 18, 2024
  • BDO-issued AmEx cardholders entitled to exclusive travel essential discounts
    BDO-issued AmEx cardholders entitled to exclusive travel essential discounts
    Paulo Papa . Mar 18, 2024
  • Mazda PH to distribute Autoexe parts, accessories
    Mazda PH to distribute Autoexe parts, accessories
    Ruben Manahan IV . Mar 18, 2024
  • Cabin check: What’s inside the BYD Atto 3
    Cabin check: What’s inside the BYD Atto 3
    Paulo Papa . Today
  • Midsize SUV battle: Hyundai Santa Fe vs. Ford Everest
    Midsize SUV battle: Hyundai Santa Fe vs. Ford Everest
    Paulo Papa . Mar 14, 2024
  • Hyundai Santa Fe: 6 seductive colors
    Hyundai Santa Fe: 6 seductive colors
    Paulo Papa . Mar 12, 2024
  • Hyundai Santa Fe vs. the competition
    Hyundai Santa Fe vs. the competition
    Paulo Papa . Mar 12, 2024
  • Luxury mover matchup: GAC M8 vs. Toyota Alphard
    Luxury mover matchup: GAC M8 vs. Toyota Alphard
    Paulo Papa . Feb 27, 2024
  • Here are some ideal destinations and safety tips for the upcoming Holy Week
    Here are some ideal destinations and safety tips for the upcoming Holy Week
    Paulo Papa . Mar 08, 2024
  • Here are some New Year’s resolutions for car owners
    Here are some New Year’s resolutions for car owners
    Paulo Papa . Jan 03, 2024
  • PH auto market: 2023 in retrospect
    PH auto market: 2023 in retrospect
    Paulo Papa . Dec 15, 2023
  • Here’s a holiday gift guide for car enthusiasts
    Here’s a holiday gift guide for car enthusiasts
    Hazel Nicole Carreon . Dec 15, 2023
  • Oil players cut pump prices anew
    Oil players cut pump prices anew
    Paulo Papa . Nov 14, 2023
  • BYD Atto 3: from the metro to the mountains
    BYD Atto 3: from the metro to the mountains
    Paulo Papa . Mar 18, 2024
  • Late bloomer: Hyundai Stargazer GLS Premium
    Late bloomer: Hyundai Stargazer GLS Premium
    Ruben Manahan IV . Mar 08, 2024
  • Adventure-ready: Subaru Crosstrek
    Adventure-ready: Subaru Crosstrek
    Paulo Papa . Mar 01, 2024
  • More doors, more fun: Suzuki Jimny 5-door
    More doors, more fun: Suzuki Jimny 5-door
    Paulo Papa . Feb 27, 2024
  • Refined ride: Volkswagen Tharu SEL
    Refined ride: Volkswagen Tharu SEL
    Paulo Papa . Feb 27, 2024